Individually assessed. Thoughtfully priced.
Every tooth deserves
an individual appraisal.
We grade and price each fossil shark tooth individually. Species, size, locality, rarity, color and preservation all contribute to its appeal and value. By considering the whole specimen and explaining its condition clearly, we help you choose with confidence—and work to make sure you are satisfied with the tooth you add to your collection.
Open the complete FGTVS grading & valuation chart (PDF) ↗
How do we grade each fossil shark tooth?
We use our Fossil Shark Tooth Grading & Valuation System (FGTVS v1.0) to describe four components individually: enamel (E), bourlette (B), root (R) and serrations (S), where applicable. The written assessment and specimen photographs explain the condition behind the rating.
Component condition grades| Component | Scores and condition | What we examine |
| Enamel (E) | E1 Poor · E2 Good · E3 Very good · E4 Excellent | Luster, scratches, divots, erosion and continuity of the light-roll reflection. |
| Bourlette (B) | B1 Poor · B2 Good · B3 Very good · B4 Excellent | Affected surface area, hydration cracks, material loss and continuity at the enamel joint. |
| Serrations (S) | S1 Poor · S2 Good · S3 Very good · S4 Excellent | Number and severity of damaged serrations, extensive erosion and translucent enamel edges. |
| Root (R) | R1 Poor · R2 Good · R3 Very good · R4 Excellent | Original outer surface and texture, nutrient pores, hydration cracking, surface loss and gouges. |
Enamel: E4 has a smooth continuous light-roll and no surface damage; E3 retains high luster with minor damage; E2 has minimal luster and extensive scratching; E1 is highly eroded with no luster.
Bourlette: B4 has seamless continuity with no scratches, hydration splits or enamel separation. B3 permits minor issues affecting no more than 4% of the surface. B2 has significant missing portions with no more than 30% loss. B1 has more than 50% missing or severely damaged.
Serrations: S4 has fully intact serrations and translucent outer enamel edges. S3 allows up to five partially damaged serrations; S2 has six or more damaged serrations; S1 has severe extensive damage or loss from wear and erosion.
Root: R4 retains the entire original surface, texture and nutrient pores without gouges, surface loss or hydration cracks. R2 permits extensive hydration cracking with no more than 20% outer-surface loss. R1 has complete loss of the original surface and texture with major hydration cracks. R3 is provisional: some hydration cracking and minimal surface loss, with limits not yet confirmed.
When is individual review required? The guide leaves bourlette loss above 30% through 50%, damage above 4% without significant loss, and root surface loss above 20% but below complete loss unassigned. These cases and provisional R3 assessments require clarification from Skye; we do not invent thresholds.
Example: E4–B4–S4–R4 = 16/16. Add the enamel, bourlette, serration and root scores. Each component is rated 1–4; the maximum overall condition score is 16.
The complete framework is intended for Megalodon, Angustidens and Chubutensis. Other species are assessed with appropriate adjustments. We do not mark naturally unserrated species down for lacking serrations, or treat a feature absent in a species as damage.
How do grades guide the price?
Our starting guide connects overall condition with an indicative value per inch. These are appraisal reference points, not automatic prices or guaranteed resale values. Every listing has its own asking price, based on the whole specimen.
FGTVS condition and starting valuation guide| Condition score | Grade | Indicative base per inch |
| 15–16 | Museum Grade (MG) | Locality-based appraisal |
| 13–14 | Collector Grade A | $700–$900 |
| 10–12 | Collector Grade B | $500–$700 |
| 8–9 | Commercial Grade A | $200–$400 |
| 7 | Commercial Grade B | $200 |
| Below 7 | Commercial Grade C | $100 or less |
Locality rarity can lower the condition score needed for Museum Grade consideration: L1 Common requires at least 15; L2 Uncommon, 14; L3 Rare, 13; and L4 Exceptional, 12. A qualifying locality assessment is considered alongside the component scores, rather than changing those scores.
The chart’s Museum Grade locality reference is L1: $1,000 per inch; L2: up to $1,500; L3: up to $2,000; and L4: $3,000+ per inch. Locality class is assessed individually from documented provenance, scarcity and collecting significance. A country name alone does not establish a rarity grade.
How do color, pattern and rare size affect value?
Color: CP0 is common coloration with no premium; CP1 is unusual coloration with a minor premium; CP2 is rare coloration that may qualify for L2 pricing; CP3 is exceptional coloration with a significant premium. White, red and green are examples to evaluate, not automatic premium grades.
Pattern: PP0 is a standard pattern with no premium; PP1 is noticeable patterning with a minor premium; PP2 is rare patterning; PP3 is exceptional patterning. Color banding, feathering and marbling are evaluated individually. PP2–PP3 may qualify for L2 pricing without changing the specimen’s actual recovery locality.
Size: SR0 is standard size; SR1 is rare size; SR2 is exceptional size. The chart flags 2-inch-plus Hemipristis serra, 3-inch-plus white shark species and Parotodus benedenii, 4-inch-plus Angustidens, and 6-inch-plus Megalodon for rare-size consideration. These appraisal thresholds are separate from the minimum-size choices in your collector profile.
The chart gives roughly $1,500 per inch as a rare-size reference and $3,000–$5,000+ per inch for exceptional examples in L3 or L4 classes. The combined rare-size examples are $2,000–$4,000 per inch with rare color, $2,500–$5,000 with L3 locality, and $3,000–$5,000+ with rare color and L4 locality. Combinations of rarity, color and size require an individual appraisal; premiums are not automatically added or multiplied. Market demand, provenance, preparation and overall desirability also influence the final asking price.
Our grades describe our assessment, not independent third-party certification. Appraisals are estimates rather than investment guarantees. Questions about a rating or price are always welcome.
How are repairs and condition explained?
Individual photographs and listing descriptions help you evaluate what you are buying. Any known repairs, restoration or polishing should be disclosed, along with condition details that affect the specimen. If a detail is unclear, contact Skye for clarification or additional views before purchasing.
How do we help you choose the right specimen?
Your satisfaction starts with understanding what matters to you. Skye can help you compare specimens, discuss their individual qualities and find a tooth that fits your collecting goals and budget. We welcome questions so you can make an informed choice.
Speak with Skye: 843-908-0227 ↗
Can we help with a special request or payment plan?
Tell Skye about your bucket-list fossil or save your collecting preferences in your account. In-house payment plan options can also be discussed directly with her, including the specimen, schedule and terms.
Share your collecting preferences ↗Explore payment plans ↗